Table of Contents

LGKG Secures $1.92 Million Jury Verdict in Case Involving Delayed Laboratory Results

We've Recovered Over 200 Million Dollars for Our Clients.

A 36-year-old man died from a pulmonary embolism after potentially critical laboratory findings were not promptly communicated to his treating physician. The case raised questions about a national laboratory’s responsibility to report potentially life-threatening test results and whether its handling of those results complied with its own reporting policies.

Attorneys at Luxenberg, Garbett, Kelly & George, P.C. (LGKG), led by Lawrence Kelly, represented the surviving family and obtained a $1.92 million jury verdict following a trial in Pennsylvania.

A Delay in Reporting Laboratory Results

The patient sought medical care, and his physician considered a possible pulmonary embolism, a potentially fatal blood clot that can block blood flow to the lungs. As part of the evaluation, the physician ordered a D-dimer test, which can help doctors assess the likelihood of a blood clot when considered alongside other clinical findings.

The patient underwent laboratory testing the following morning. Although some results reached the physician’s office the next day, the D-dimer result was missing.

The physician’s office contacted the laboratory to request the outstanding result. Staff were informed that the test had been sent to another facility for processing. A second inquiry was made the following day, but the result was still unavailable to the physician’s office.

The D-dimer result became available that evening. It measured 5.97, approximately 12 times the laboratory’s normal cutoff. However, instead of contacting the physician directly, the laboratory transmitted the result electronically to the physician’s office late that night, when the office was closed.

The patient died from a pulmonary embolism the following afternoon.

Challenging the Laboratory's Reporting Practices

LGKG’s case centered on whether the elevated D-dimer finding should have been classified as a critical result under the national laboratory’s own policies. The firm argued that the result met the laboratory’s definition of a finding requiring immediate physician attention because of the potential for serious harm or death.

According to the firm’s argument, the laboratory’s policy required critical results to be communicated to the physician’s office within two hours of becoming available, regardless of the day or time.

The defense disputed that interpretation, maintaining that the D-dimer result did not qualify as critical under its policies.

During the trial, LGKG presented the laboratory’s reporting requirements and asked the jury to determine whether the result should have triggered the critical-result notification procedure. The firm’s position was that the failure to promptly alert the treating physician deprived the patient of a timely opportunity for further medical evaluation.

Presenting the Full Impact of the Loss

Beyond the circumstances of the delayed test result, LGKG presented evidence concerning the patient’s life, family relationships, and future earning potential.

The patient had previously worked as a heavy equipment operator and had obtained a commercial driver’s license while pursuing new employment opportunities. Working with an economist, the firm presented evidence supporting approximately $1 million in projected lost earnings over the remainder of the patient’s expected working life.

The trial also addressed the personal impact of the death on the patient’s surviving family, particularly his father, who discovered him at home.

Through testimony, LGKG described the family’s close relationships and the emotional consequences of losing a loved one unexpectedly. These details helped the jury consider both the financial losses and the human impact of the death.

A $1.92 Million Jury Verdict

The jury returned a $1.92 million verdict.

The result followed the firm’s decision to take the case to trial after settlement discussions failed to produce an offer the firm considered reasonable. Attorney Lawrence Kelly headed the trial team, overseeing the presentation of evidence, witness testimony, and key legal arguments. His leadership helped secure the $1.92 million jury verdict for the surviving family.

The case illustrates the importance of timely communication of potentially serious medical findings and the role a jury may play in determining whether a laboratory complied with its reporting obligations.

For LGKG, the verdict reflected the firm’s willingness to pursue a case through trial when it believed the proposed settlement did not adequately address the family’s losses.

Reach Out to Us

Schedule a Free Consultation

Having represented over 10,000 clients, we’ve brought more cases to trial than many attorneys in Western PA

Other Case Results

Verdict

Dangerous Berm Drop-Off Causes Rollover: Historic $1.5 Million Verdict Against A State Agency

Oct. 14, 2005, a Lawrence County jury returned a verdict of $1.5 million on behalf of a Lawrence County man who was injured as a result of a hazardous condition on a PennDOT highway. According to the Lawrence County Prothonotary…

Verdict

Hospital Delay Causes Infant's Fingers to Self-Amputate: Seven-Figure Verdict

The plaintiff, a minor child, was in the neonatal intensive care unit of the defendant/hospital, where failure to remove an arterial line resulted in amputation. The jury found in favor of the plaintiffs. 

Settlement

Ignored Fetal Distress Signals Cause Permanent Brain Damage: Seven-Figure Settlement

The plaintiff, a minor child, was diagnosed with periventricular leukomalacia and spasticity following his birth. Prior to his birth, there was evidence of intrauterine growth restrictions, which necessitated the need of biophysical profiles…

Verdict

Dangerous Berm Drop-Off Causes Rollover: Historic $1.5 Million Verdict Against A State Agency

Oct. 14, 2005, a Lawrence County jury returned a verdict of $1.5 million on behalf of a Lawrence County man who was injured as a result of a hazardous condition on a PennDOT highway. According to the Lawrence County Prothonotary, the jury award was the highest in the history of the county at that time. It still remains the highest verdict against a state agency.

On Sept. 16, 2000, the plaintiff was operating his vehicle in a westerly direction on SR 2028 when he saw a dog in his lane of traffic. After steering his vehicle to avoid the dog, the passenger side tires dropped off the paved portion of the roadway onto the berm. When he attempted to steer his vehicle left back onto the paved surface, it was unresponsive. As a result, the vehicle struck an embankment and rolled over several times.

The law firm of Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George, P.C., hired an expert witness who was an employee of PennDOT for 32 years. The expert testified that the PennDOT Maintenance Manual stated that any berm drop-off in excess of 2 inches is a hazardous condition. The expert testified that upon inspection of the roadway in question, the berm drop-off ranged anywhere from 2 to 7 inches and that such a berm drop-off substantially affected the plaintiff’s ability to steer his vehicle safely back onto the roadway.

The law firm of Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George, P.C., hired a vocational expert who offered testimony regarding the plaintiff’s loss of past and future wages and loss of earning capacity.

The law firm of Luxenberg Garbett Kelly & George, P.C., offered the testimony of a physician who specializes in physical medicine and rehabilitation. The physician offered testimony regarding the plaintiff’s limitations as a result of this accident.

The jury deliberated for approximately two hours, 15 minutes before returning a verdict in the amount of $1.5 million.

Verdict

Hospital Delay Causes Infant's Fingers to Self-Amputate: Seven-Figure Verdict

The plaintiff, a minor child, was in the neonatal intensive care unit of the defendant/hospital. A radial arterial line was placed to measure blood pressure and to have access to arterial blood for lab analysis. When the hand showed signs of circulatory compromise, the arterial line was not removed. After the line was eventually discontinued, the fingers turned black and self-amputated. The plaintiff’s experts contended that the failure to remove the line at the first sign of circulatory compromise was a deviation of the standard of care.

The jury found in favor of the plaintiffs. The verdict with delay damages was seven figures.

Settlement

Ignored Fetal Distress Signals Cause Permanent Brain Damage: Seven-Figure Settlement

The plaintiff, a minor child, was diagnosed with periventricular leukomalacia and spasticity following his birth. Prior to his birth, there was evidence of intrauterine growth restrictions, which necessitated the need of biophysical profiles, twice weekly nonstress testing and serial scans to monitor fetal growth. On the day of his birth, there was evidence that the fetus was suffering from fetal distress, which necessitated an urgent cesarean section. During the admission, fetal heart tracings provided objective evidence that the fetus was in distress and the failure to follow the standard of care by the doctors and nursing staff was a substantial factor in causing the child’s injury and harm.

Following five days of trial, the case was settled for seven figures.